Social class identity

Def. a group who share similar economic and social situation

Derives from the work we do

Income, status and lifestyle come from it

Less significant to some people today so argued that class is dead

Lead to social class developing similar norms and values cultures and lifestyle so effects on individual’s identity

Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste and form of Capital

Class fractions are determined by social, economic and cultural capital

Includes income, wealth and financial inheritance

Economic Capital

Includes income, wealth and financial inheritance

Achieved or ascribed

Social classes with the most tends to be those with high paid jobs or have a lot of inherited wealth

Cultural Capital

Includes cultural attributes and often related to education such as classical music, art and literature

Ascribed because it’s difficult to buy and achieve

Thought children educated in leading public schools so they gain from family so gives them a high status in society

Social Capital

Includes resources based on social connections and group membership

Mainly done through networking and relationships with different groups of people

Largely achieved and possessed by different classes in different ways

Traditional working class High social class
Frequently look at others interest through employment and through exchanging services Done through education and networks of children who attend some education

All 3 capitals are interested

Someone with high levels of one type is more likely to be able to attain the others well

Cultural capital = most significant such as parents teach children to speak the right way

Marxism

Influenced by the work of Karl Marx (1818-1883)

Every society means of production which determines the way society is organised

Argued that in almost every society there is two classes

He observed the modern capitalist system and saw a growing wealth gab between them

Lied to a communist society where everyone gets four shares

Power of the ruling class allows them to define the knowledge and skills that are valued

Postmodernism

Believe that it is impossible to have one general, overall theory

Change society very quickly

Social class take more notice of culture the traditional Marxist theory

An individual who is no longer controlled by big, powerful social structure so have a range of choices

Consumer culture is possible for individuals to pick and choose identities based on what they consume so old class boundaries blurring into one so makes society based on conspicuous consumption

Conspicuous consumption provides creation for own lifestyle as people are earning higher wages which allows them to buy what they want

Shown how to do this by the mass media which is influenced in all areas of life

Social classes are fragmenting due to globalisation such as people migrating and change traditional class structures

Social mobility has increased as identity is not fixed for life as we’re individuals and no one’s life is better

Upper Class Identity

Traditionally defined by its wealth, privilege aristocratic titles and possession of high culture

Ascribed status so inherited their wealth and title

Mackintosh and Mooney (2004)

Wealth and privilege are not always visible

Maintained by the elite view

Educating children in separate and distinct private schools independent of state control

Marry from the same circle and keep money in the family

Social closure is where they keep themselves separate from other classes

Old boy network is to gain access to the top jobs

This goes against the idea of meritocracy such as a barrister

Been challenged through the super-rich so gain fortune through talent and business such as footballers and lord sugar

The super-rich are distinctive by their celebrity status conspicuous consumption and lavish lifestyle

Achieved via hard work or talent rather than inherited so children of them inherit their status

Middle Class Identity

Majority of the population

Traditionally associated with non-manual work as long periods of training in skilled professional work such as law and medicine

Own houses

Great deal of status as well as cultural capital and social capital

Very aspirational and highly value education and mainly higher education

Diverse group and very different income attitudes and lifestyle

Fox (2004)

Upper middle class = barristers

Middle middle class = teachers

Lower middle class = clerical workers

Employed in public sector are thought to be altruistic

Employed in private sector are thought to be individual

Savage (1995)

  • different types of middle-class identity
  1. Professionals – success due to education so value knowledge and life style
  2. Cultural capital so wealth in forms of obedience
  3. Managers so success means a high standard of living
  4. Entrepreneurial group so identity revolves around consumption of high and popular culture

The Working Class

Decline in trade union membership and manufacturing sector

Romanticised as a hardworking, straight talking and salt of the earth identity

Clearly middle class in terms of education, career or income

Skeggs (1997)

Working class woman felt humiliated by the ways in which others judged and dismissed them due to their background

Woman made a strenuous effect to show they were respectable taking care in how they dress, their leisure, pursuits and home decorations

Old Working Class

Traditional until the 20th and strong sense of identity and bound up with employment

Gender identities so breadwinner and housewife

Extended families

Low educational expectations – level 2

Heavy industry job

Immediate gratification

Restricted speech code

Associated with old labour party and trade unions

New Working Class

Lack a sense of community

Move towards service sector as heavily industry jobs have declined

Focus on standard of living not their occupation

Decline in immediate gratification and growing

Decline in extended families but more in cohabitation and child centred

Social mobility through education and work so university and professionals’ job

Move towards home ownership as in 1980s Margret Thatcher introduced the Housing Act

Lash and Urry (1994)

Came up by de centring of class identity as they acre about living standards

Gold Thorpe and Lockwood (1960s) called these privatised instrumentalists

The Under Class

Exist on state benefits, low paid and part time work

Saunders (1990) says it is a distinct subculture that becomes dependent on sate support

Jordan (1992) argues they hold the same values as the rest of society but held back by circumstances

They do use and do; foul language, social housing, single parents, welfare dependency, teenage pregnancy, many sexual partners, fake designer clothes and crime

Charles Murray (1984)

Argues that over-generous benefits encourage some people develop a culture or set of norms and values and don’t take responsibility for their own actions

Studied in USA and 1989 and British underclass

Live off mainstream society without participant

Labels, understanding, not respectful and feckless poor

Juvenile delinquents and children contribute

Type of poverty

Governments are unsurprisingly concerned about the group so low education as raising the school age

Showed in negative ways in media such as the Jeremy Kyle show