The Versailles Peace Settlement and Attempts at Disarmament

1919-20 – Paris Peace Conference

  • The leaders (the Big Three) of the winning countries of World War One were involved
    • Britain – David Lloyd George
    • France – Georges Clemenceau
    • USA – Woodrow Wilson
  • The Big Three decided what punishment would be given to the loosing countries
    • Wilson had 14 Points which embodied his vision for the post-war world; these included no secret treaties, free access to seas, free trade, all countries disarmament, colonies to have choices, League of Nations
  • All three had different views on how to treat the loosing countries, specifically Germany
    • Clemenceau wanted to be harsh on Germany to guarantee it could never pose a threat to France in future and totally destabilise it
      • He had witnessed the Franco Prussian War
      • The French Electorate would never have allowed him to be lenient
    • Lloyd George wanted to be lenient to Germany, so it would stay strong in order to trade with them and that no revolution would be caused
    • Wilson wanted lasting international peace by being lenient towards Germany
    • Both Lloyd George and Wilson disagreed with Clemenceau over how to treat Germany
    • Lloyd George and Wilson disagreed about all nations having access to seas and self-determination for colonies as these would threaten the British Empire

1919 – Treaty of Versailles

  • The Big Three drew up the Treaty of Versailles which was the main treaty between the three and Germany
  • None of them were completely happy with it however they compromised
    • Germany had to take full blame for beginning the war
    • Germany was forced to pay £6.6billion in reparations
    • Germany lost 10% of its land including Alsace-Lorraine as well as overseas colonies
    • Germany had to shrink its army to 100 000 soldiers, 6 battleships, no submarines or aircrafts and a demilitarised Rhineland
    • Germany was not allowed to unite with Austria
    • Germany was not allowed to become a member of the newly set-up League of Nations
  • Many Germans did not believe that they had lost the war and therefore they believed they were being treated very unfairly
  • Germany was not represented at the conference which would make the outcome unfair whatever happened
  • The Germans believed that they were not solely to blame for starting the war, so they were upset that they were blamed
  • The disarmament terms were deemed unfair as none of the winning countries had to disarm
  • Germans were appalled at loosing land as many natives found themselves under foreign rule
  • The reparations forced upon Germany put them in total economic decline
  • Germany was humiliated by not being allowed to join the League of Nations

1919-20 – Other Treaties

  • Treaty of St Germain with Austria
    • Army limited to 30 000 soldiers
    • Empire broken, and colonies taken
    • Forbidden to unite with Germany
  • Treaty of Neuilly with Bulgaria
    • Army limited to 20 000 soldiers
    • Paid £10million in reparations
    • Land lost to Greece, Romania and Yugoslavia
  • Treaty of Trianon with Hungry
    • Supposed to pay reparations but was to poor
    • Land lost to Romania, Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia
  • Treaty of Sevres with Turkey
    • Army severely limited
    • Lost much of its empire to Britain and France
    • Land lost to Italy and Greece
    • Turkey used force to reverse some of the terms of this treaty which was set out in a new one called the Treaty of Lausanne in 1923

1920s – The League of Nations

  • It was an international organisation to preserve world peace and solve disputes without war
    • There were 42 founding members
  • All members had to sign a covenant which set out its structure, rules and aims
  • It’s structure
    • Secretariat – staff of permanent office workers who dealt with day-to-day running
    • Commissions – tackled general international problems and made important achievements, including:
      • Refugee Committee – helped approximately 400 000 displaced people return to their homes post-war
      • International Labour Organisation – successfully campaigned for worker’s rights
      • Declaration of the Rights of the Child – still in place today
      • Health Committee – funded research into curing deadly diseases
      • Financial Committee – came up with economic plans to help countries recover from the war
    • Council – met five times a year plus in emergencies as leaders of the league
    • Assembly – parliament of the league which met 1X per year to vote on budgeting and letting in new members etc
    • Court of International Justice – settled disputes between countries
  • Its rules were
    • No countries could go to war
    • All countries must strive to have good relations with others
    • Governments must act according to the international law
    • Nations must maintain justice and respect for all treaty obligations
  • Its aims were
    • Promote international cooperation
    • Achieve international peace and security
    • Discourage aggression
    • Encourage disarmament
    • Boost international trade and business
    • Improve living and working conditions
    • Enforce terms of treaties
  • The League began with 42 member-nations in 1919 but by 1939 there were over 50
  • The strongest influences were Britain and France who were in it from 1919-45, along with Italy, Japan, Germany and the USSR
  • USA were not in the League as despite it being the president’s idea, congress voted against it
  • Each of the Big Three had different visions for the League:
    • Wilson – a world parliament with regular meetings
    • Clemenceau – a strong body with its own army
    • Lloyd George – a simple group to meet in emergencies

1921-30 – Problems Dealt with by the League

  • 1921 – Aaland Islands dispute was successful for the League
    • Finland and Sweden both claimed ownership of the Aaland Islands
    • Both sides threatened to go to war
    • The League ruled that Finland owned the islands and Sweden accepted it
  • 1921 – Upper Silesian settlement was successful for the League
    • Germany and Poland both claimed ownership of Upper Silesia
    • The League oversaw a peaceful plebiscite and divided the region between the countries
  • 1923 – Corfu crisis was a failure for the League
    • Mussolini of Italy blamed Greece for the death of a top army general – Tellini – and demanded compensation
    • The Greeks refused to pay resulting in Mussolini invading the Greek island of Corfu
    • This was a violation of the covenant of the League, so Greece appealed for help
    • The League condemned Mussolini’s actions however, they also recommended that Greece pay Italy the compensation
    • Italy refused to accept this, so appealed to The Conference of Ambassadors
    • The Greeks were told to apologise and pay compensation directly to Italy
  • 1920-29 – Vilna: Polish-Lithuanian dispute was a failure for the League
    • Poland took control of the Lithuanian capital, Vilna
    • Lithuania appealed to the League and the League protested to Poland
    • The Poles did not pull out
  • 1925 – Bulgaria was a success for the League
    • Some Greek soldiers were killed on the border with Bulgaria
    • Greek troops invaded Bulgaria who appealed to the League for help
    • The League ruled that both should stand down and the Greeks must withdraw
    • Britain and France backed the ruling resulting in the Greeks obeying
  • In some of these cases internationalism triumphed whilst in others, nationalism did
  • When Britain and France worked together to back the League, they were successful

1920s – Disarmament

  • It was the League’s role to ensure that all countries followed through with the disarmament process as stated in the treaties
  • It largely failed in this aim
  • At the Washington Conference in 1921, the USA, Japan, Britain and France agreed to limit the size of their navies however, this was as far as it got
  • This was particularly damaging to the League’s reputation in Germany as it had disarmed
  • International agreements occurred during the 1920s
    • 1922 – Rapallo Treaty – the USSR and Germany re-established diplomatic relations
    • 1924 – Dawes Plan – the USA loaned money to Germany to help stabilise it and pay reparations
    • 1925 – Locarno Treaties – Germany finally accepted its western borders to be as set out in the Treaty of Versailles
    • 1928 – Kellog-Briand Pact – 65 nations agreed that they would not use force to settle disputes
    • 1929 – Young Plan – reduced the amount of German reparations
  • These agreements were not carried out by the League but by the countries themselves
  • However, some say these international agreements were achievements of the League as it developed an ‘internationalist mind-set’

Outline the views of President Wilson about peace-making in 1919. [5]

Outline the views of Lloyd George about peace making in 1919. [5]

Describe the main concerns of Lloyd George and Clemenceau at the Paris Peace Conference in 1919. [5]

Outline the setting up of the League of Nations in 1919-20. [5]

Outline the punishment of Germany’s allies in the treaties at the Paris Peace Conference in 1919. [5]

Outline the attempts by the League of Nations to maintain international peace in the 1920s. [5]

Explain why the League was un/successful at solving some disputes between nations in the 1920s. [5]

Explain why there were disagreements between the Big Three at the peace talks in Paris in 1919. [10]

Explain why there were protests against the Treaty of Versailles when it was issued in 1919. [10]

Explain why the League of Nations had so much popular support when it was established. [10]

Explain why the humanitarian work of the League of Nations in the 1920s is generally seen as a success. [10]