Why isn’t parliamentary debate effective?

  1. OPPOSITION
  • The opposition can only choose the topic for debate on 20 days of the parliamentary year (‘opposition days’)
  • Gov suffered a rare defeat on an opposition motion in 2010 when Liberal Democrats initiated a debate on the Brown government’s refusal to grant citizenship to Ghurkhas who had served in the UK armed forces.
  1. TURNOUT
  • Debates are poorly attended except at times of crisis.
  • In 2017, only 30 MPs turned up for a debate on the Humanitarian Crisis in Yemen and in 2016 gov held an urgent debate on Aleppo and only a handful of MPs went.