What puts a strain on Collective Ministerial Responsibility?

  1. LEAKS
  • Disgruntled ministers may leak cabinet info to the media.
  • g. Ed Balls and Nick Clegg revealed cabinet discussions in their books.
  1. DISSENT/NON-RESIGNATION
  • Cabinet members that oppose important parts of gov policy have survived in office even when their concerns have been made public.
  • g. many LD ministers were critical of coalition policy 2010-2015 but only one junior minister resigned. 
  1. DOMINANCE OF PM
  • Some ministers that served under Thatcher and Blair claimed that they undermined CR by ignoring the cabinet.
  • Mo Mowlam and Clare Short complained that Blair did not consult the cabinet sufficiently.