What are the main electoral systems?

  1. MAJORITARIAN
  • The winning candidate must secure an absolute majority of the vote.
  • Candidates are usually elected in single-member constituencies.
  • The output of FPTP could be described as majoritarian because the voters who’s candidates didn’t win are not reflected in Parliament.
  • In 2015, 50% of all votes go to a losing candidate and 24% also went to a candidate that had already secured enough votes to win.
  1. PROPORTIONAL
  • Produces a close fit between votes and seats, although no system can deliver perfect proportionality.
  • The district magnitude is crucial — the larger the constituency, the more proportional the result.
  • PR systems use multi-member constituencies and electoral formulas to match the percentage of votes won by each party to the percentage of votes they won.
  • Some (e.g. the single transferable vote) allow electors to vote for as many candidates as they wish in order of preference, whereas others (e.g. the closed list system) permit only a single vote.
  • Elections to Scottish local government (councils) use an electoral system called the Single Transferable Vote (STV). STV was first used in Scotland in 2007.
  1. PLURALITY
  • FPTP is a single-member plurality system in which the winner needs only a plurality of votes cast, not an absolute majority.
  • Plurality systems share characteristics of majoritarian systems in that (in the case of the UK) the plurality system produces a majoritarian outcome.
  • In 2010, when 2/3 of MPs did not gain a majority in their constituency and it consequently allows parties to form a government with only a small share of the vote.
  • Produces a disproportional outcome.
  1. MIXED
  • Combines elements of the plurality or majoritarian systems with elements of proportional representation.
  • g. AMS. Some representatives are elected in single-member constituencies using first-past-the-post.
  • The remainder are elected by proportional representation in multi-member constituencies.
  • Seats are allocated to parties on corrective lines to represent their share of the vote proportionally
  • Used in Scottish parliament and Welsh Assembly.