Tulving: Procedural & Declarative

Semantic:

  • Facts, meaning and knowledge.
  • Information about ourselves, stores information about the world.
  • Involves conscious thought & doesn’t rely on cue’s for retrieval.
  • Can work independently.
  • Found in frontal & temporal lobe.
  • Fragmented structure.

Episodic:

  • Encodes on cues which trigger recall, gives a sense of identity.
  • Stores information about events (who, what, where) & involves conscious thought.
  • Stores memories chronologically (date stamped).
  • Gives emotional & entire context surroundings of events.
  • Helps remember past experiences & relies on semantics.
  • If not triggered by cue there could be failure to retrieve.
  • Found in hippocampus.

Procedural:

  • Motor skills memory.
  • Emotional behaviours.
  • Knowing how to do things, performing skills.
  • Not aware of able to recall memories.
  • Doesn’t involve conscious thought.
Strengths Weaknesses
Clive Wearing – have widespread damage to the brain meaning they cannot produce new episodal & semantic memories. However can still remember motor skills like piano – showing that there are separate areas of the brain for semantic, procedural & episodic

Hm – person had parts of hippocampus & temporal lobes removed to stop seizures which damaged his episodic & semantic memory – showing different areas of brain responsible for memory as procedural skills still working.

Application – Tulving demonstrates the importance of cues to improve episodic memory – helps educational rehabilitation by learner’s effort to identify cues helping retention.

Low G – case studies are usually unique and damage cannot be replicated – e.g HM temporal & hippocampus removed – cannot generalise these to everyone as they are unique.

Doesn’t account for continuity between each system as they work together e.g when episodic tasks like learning a list of words, it uses both semantic & episodic features – unable to study separate memory functions in isolation.

Contrasting theory – Atkin & Shiffrin – states that LTM is just one store and that it is simplistic & only one store for procedural, semantic & episodic memory – stating Tulving is over complicating memory